Book Review: The Content Pool by Alan J. Porter
The Accidental Content Strategist

The Fate of Books

London library damaged during the blitz

This is a picture of the London Library after being damaged, rather substantially, during the blitz. I came across this image when re-reading The History of Reading by Alberto Manguel. When you take the time to consider this picture you are struck by how incredible it is and how much it can tell us about the nature of books. This is exactly what Manguel does. We can do the same right now. 

For starters, we see one of the features of printed books that is always noteworthy and that is their robustness. Certainly many books would have been obliterated by the initial explosion. Others would have been soaked as the London Fire Brigade battled the attendant flames. But a great many books would have survived. I have touched on the persistence of books before (see The eBook Revolution: Blowing Books to Bits) and the importance of this quality is worth returning to from time to time. 

But as Manguel points out, there is a lot more here as well. Most notably, instead of the bustle of emergency workers we find people who probably arrived to survey the damage but who have been distracted by the books on the shelves. They immediately revealed themselves as incurable readers, as seekers of knowledge. Now I cannot but help seeing one of the quintessential qualities of the British, a stubborn fascination with learning, and then seeing this as one of the reasons why Britain never flinched during the onslaught and invariably prevailed. 

We also see here a common fate of libraries. As has been chronicled in a number of books, libraries have a nasty habit of falling afoul of forces who seek to strike at the heart of any given society by striking at their libraries. As two examples, see A Universal History of the Destruction of Books and Books on Fire: The Destruction of Libraries throughout History. There is a perverse logic at work in these cases. The mainstays of a society will seek to collect, enshrine and protect what it knows, believes and values in institutions that declare, quite physically, the importance of these resources. Hence libraries. And hence the specialized communities that build up around them with these sometimes being very exclusive communities (just try wondering into the Bodleian Library without a readers card, for example). When strife appears, these institutions quickly become targets. In other instances, an earnest but expensive lattice work of investments is erected around these institutions which attracts the attention of a more pedestrian enemy. Funding cutbacks inevitably follow. This circumstance has led me on occasion to make a highly uncharitable substitution of librarians for lawyers in one of Shakespeare's more notorious declarations about what do with lawyers. 

Interior of the Beinecke Library

More interesting to me than the destruction of books and libraries, however, is their remarkable ability to survive. The more common fate for libraries than destruction is in fact their dispersal. When the investment needed to manage and protect a library wanes, what usually happens is that the holdings are boxed up, shipped out, sold off, or in some cases simply pillaged. Then the books enter a wider circulation and one that is usually uncharted. This is where things tend to get really interesting, to my mind. Unchained (sometimes quite literally) from their shelves, ex libris books have often travelled widely and sparked unforeseen consequences. So while the learning circle that grew up around John Dee and his Elizabethan library is noteworthy, the dispersal of the books and the new circles it might have spawned is even more interesting. The same can be said of the renaissance library of Matthias Corvinus, the Raven King of Hungary. The holdings of this library, filled with some of the latest and most exquisite examples of scriptorial art, found themselves being spread widely across Europe and the Islamic world. Books that were once only accessed by the invited few suddenly found themselves in the bargain bin of history, accessible to anyone with some spare change.

Used Books and Avid Readers

I am also reminded of a story I remember hearing about the early Bodleian Library when investigators dispatched under a reactionary Queen Mary (aka Bloody Mary) found that about 300 of the 303 volumes in the library should be classified as prohibited. I have a fanciful image of clerics running out of the library in a state of horror after having encountered volume after volume of astrology, magical science and heretical philosophy. The immediate consequence of this investigation might have been the destruction of the books but I can't help but think that the tomes would have simply shifted around the town of Oxford thereby remaining in unofficial circulation. (I have not expended any energy on researching this further, as I am sure that someone has looked into it. And I suspect that I will prefer my version of the story over what I might discover. Nonetheless, the more than a little quirky, and at times irreverent, nature of many Oxford scholars - then as now - leads me to be quite confident that at least some of the prohibited books found a life after being proscribed.) 

The persistence of books does have a material bearing on how this pattern of dissemination has operated in the past. Now the emergence of electronic books offers us new channels of movement, and ones that operate at the speed of light. The persistence of these electronic artifacts does become an interesting topic to consider. In some ways, the unbridled replication that theoretically comes with digital representations may make these electronic books highly persistent. In other ways, however, electronic formats have a habit of falling out of favour, or disk drive space oddly becomes a precious resource to be protected through ham-fisted purges, and information that was once widely available can suddenly find itself to be very rare indeed.

Even in my own experience, the mountains of electronic documents written and posted on the early web - ironically frequently about digitizing information resources and business processes - have all but vanished. So it seems that some of the forces that regularly threaten books and libraries do not distinguish between the hardcopy and the digital. We should be mindful of this fact as we move more and more of our books online. And we should think seriously about how we can bolster, instead of undermining, the persistence and portability of books in a digital world. I suspect that more depends on this than we currently understand. 


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Marcia Riefer Johnston

Thought-provoking as always, Joe. Wonderful photos. I like your phrase "bargain bin of history." As a book lover--and an author about to come out with my own book in both print and ebook formats--I find this topic especially compelling. Whatever form tomorrow's books may take, long may they live!


Joe Gollner

Hi Marcia

Yes, the "bargain bin of history" does have a nice ring to it. I imagine that is where I will wind up someday.

And yes, I too would wish books well regardless of the physical form that they may take. So perhaps in addition to wishing them long life we can also wish them safe travels...


Mary Davidson

Hi Joe,
Re; The fate of Books. It struck me that as history would have it To wipe out a philosophy, culture or religion, the burning or ban of books was always a good way to do it. Now we are in the electronic age hiding the literature would be harder as it would be in many vaults, of a different nature.
Aunt Mary

Joe Gollner

Hi Mary and good to bump into you online

As is often the case, technological change can cut both ways - both giving something and taking something away. In the case of electronic books, the ability for materials to move around the world in an instant - circumventing physical boundaries and finding hiding places on hard drives and smart phones - definitely gives us a number of things. However technology can now be used to limit where content can travel and to monitor who accesses it and when. In these ways books in a digital world may be less portable and accessible than before, which is sort of ironic.

Take for example buying a book. If I do it at a used book stall and I pay with cash, no one will ever no that I have purchased this book or that I read it the following day. With an electronic book, it is a matter of digital record that I purchased a book, or checked it out of an online library, and the record would continue with exactly when I purchased it, what device I was using at the time, where I was at the time and so on. And as I am reading the book, my eReader can be collecting information and dispatching it for analysis and it could track how I am reading the book, what parts I am rereading, and where I have added bookmarks and notes (and what those notes say). So if I was somewhere in the world where what I was reading was prohibited it is more than theoretically possible for there to be suddenly a knock at the door, and this time its a real knock on a real door.

And by a similar token, it is far from impossible for deletion instructions, or corruption routines, to be unleashed that attack electronic books with specific content. When Amazon decided to take away an electronic book from all customers, the public was awoken to the fact that this sort of thing was possible, albeit in this case within a specific "marketplace" (being Amazon).

But with all that said and done, I do ultimately side with you in being hopeful that in the electronic domain we will find better ways to thwart those who want to seek and destroy books and what they represent and facilitate.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)